Written by RuinMyTrip Editorial from published research and official sources, not from a personal trip. It is not a traveler review and is never counted in the community rating. How we research.
What it is
A landmark hotel on West 23rd Street in Chelsea, Manhattan, reopened after a long restoration, with rooms from 200 sq ft, a lobby bar, El Quijote and a Japanese restaurant in the building.
Why travelers stay here
For the building. Very few hotels anywhere have this much cultural history still legible in the fabric, and the restoration kept the staircase, the ironwork and the art rather than replacing them.
What is genuinely good
A genuinely historic building handled with care, the staircase and lobby art, El Quijote next door, and a Chelsea address within walking distance of the High Line and the Village.
Downsides
Small standard rooms. A lobby that functions partly as a tourist attraction. No published rates, and accessible rooms require emailing to book.
Best for
Anyone with an interest in twentieth-century music, writing or art, and anyone who would rather stay somewhere specific than somewhere large.
Consider staying elsewhere if
You need space, or you want a quiet anonymous hotel. Neither describes this building.
Practical advice
Book above the Petite category if 200 sq ft sounds tight, because it is. Accessible rooms have to be arranged by email, so allow time. Eat at El Quijote at least once.
Rates and booking
Nightly rates are not published as a fixed figure and vary with season and demand. Check current rates on the hotel's official booking page. Accessible rooms are booked by emailing the hotel.
Getting there
Subway 1 to 23rd Street, or C and E to 23rd Street, both a few minutes away. It is on West 23rd between Seventh and Eighth.
Where it sits
West 23rd Street in Chelsea, walking distance to the High Line, Chelsea Market, the gallery district and the West Village.
How long to stay
Two to three nights.
The RuinMyTrip verdict
Stay for the building, and book a category above Petite. The restoration kept what mattered, which almost no one expected.
Sources
- The Petite Chelsea room has a queen bed and is 200 sq ft, about 19 sq m. source
- Accessible rooms have a king bed and are approximately 450 sq ft, and are booked by email rather than online. source